10 Most Underrated NBA Players of All Time

10 Most Underrated NBA Players of All Time

10 Most Underrated NBA Players of All Time

1) Moses Malone
Best Season: 31.1 PPG, 14.7 RPG, 1.5 BPG, FG% .519
Larry Bird once remarked if he had one person to start a franchise around it would be Moses. Often overlooked in favor of big men such as Wilt, Russ, Kareem, Hakeem and Shaq. Moses belongs in this group. He was able to win 3 MVP awards throughout his career. He also helped Philadelphia to a championship in 1983. Holds the single season offensive rebounding record with over 550 (7.2 per game). During the 1982 season he averaged over 30 points and 15 rebounds in route to an MVP award. He was the six time rebounding champion and appeared in 13 All-Star games. When the ABA forced a merged with the NBA, Malone was only 20 years old. Several teams had a shot to sign the bulldozer. The Portland Trailblazers made one of their blunders by trading away Malone and getting little in return. During the same time the New York Knicks had a chance to acquire the future MVP, but claimed the asking price was too high. The Knicks haven't won a championship since.

2) Bob McAdoo
Best Season: 34.5 PPG, 14.1 RPG, 2.2 APG, 2.1 BPG, FG% .512
McAdoo led the NBA in scoring for three straight seasons starting in 1973. The 1975 MVP had a great inside/outside game, McAdoo was an accomplished shooter at 6'10. He was excellent at drawing fouls as well. He had to miss a considerable amount of time due to injury in the early 1980s. Last player to average 30 points & 15 rebounds in a season. The 5 time all-star, was able to thrive as a role player later in his career with the Los Angeles Lakers. During his four years with the Lakers he was a prolific scorer off the bench, helping LA to 2 NBA titles.

3) Dennis Rodman
Best Season: 9.8 PPG, 18.7 RPG, 2.3 APG, 1.1 BPG, FG% .539
The King of intangibles, Rodman's effect on the game was hard to calculate. Written off as a late draft pick, Rodman was defensive player capable of changing the game. The worm led the league in rebounds for 7 straight seasons starting in 1992. The heart and soul of the bay boys Pistons teams, helped them to back to back championships in 1989 and 1990. Rodman would then team with the Chicago Bulls in 1996 and help them to a three-peat. Named NBA All-Defensive First Team honors seven times. He won the defensive player of the year award twice. People often underrated Rodman's abilities on the court because of his off the court behaviors. But this is no question the Pistons do not win back to back championships without Rodman.

4) Rick Barry
Best Season: 35.6 PPG, 9.2 RPG, 3.6 APG, FG% .451
Taken 2nd overall in the 1965 NBA Draft, Barry dominated both the NBA & ABA. Often known to be difficult and demanding he did little to endear himself to the media. Barry was an underrated defender who competed with the best of wing players of his time. He was able to lead the NBA and ABA in scoring 5 different seasons. His 30.5 points per game average in the ABA stands as the highest career total for a player in any professional basketball league. Barry helped take the Warriors to the 1967 NBA Finals, in which he had a 55-point outburst in Game 3, Barry averaged 40.8 points per game in the series, an NBA Finals record that stood for three decades. One of the best free throw shooters of all time employing an underhand granny style shot. Rick was able to lead the Warriors to the 1975 title, beating the Washington Bullets in one of the biggest upsets of all time.

5) Tracy McGrady
Best Season: 32.1 PPG, 6.5 RPG, 5.5 APG, 1.7 SPG, FG% .457
Kobe Bryant once admitted the player that gave him the most trouble in his career was Tracy McGrady. The 6'9 shooting guard wowed fans and clowned defenders during his reign in the early 2000's. Perhaps the best one-on-one ball handler over 6'6 in NBA history. A dominant offensive force, he led the league in scoring in back to back seasons for Orlando. McGrady was a seven time All-Star and seven time All-NBA selection. More often than not, bad luck and injuries got McGrady bounced out of the playoffs early. However, he never had the pieces around him to make his teams serious title contenders. From a pure talent standpoint, few can argue with his ability.

6) Elvin Hayes
Best Season: 27.5 PPG, 16.9 RPG, 2.0 APG, FG% .452
The turnaround jump shot belongs to Elvin Hayes. Traditionally thought of as selfish and distant. Elvin proved his doubters wrong in the 1978 NBA championship, displaying the ability to share the ball and play defense. Big E dominated on defense averaging almost 3 blocks and 2 steals in the 1978 playoffs. Hayes currently stands 9th on the NBA career scoring list. 1969 scoring Champ, twelve time all star, two time rebound champ and six time All-NBA selection.

7) George McGinnis
Best Season: 29.8 PPG, 14,7 RPG, 6.3 APG, 2.6 SPG, FG% .450
A driving force for the NBA and ABA in the 70s. A high scoring forward out of Indiana University. An underrated rebounder, McGinnis used his versatile scoring to dominant smaller opponents and take bigger matchups off the dribble. Crafty footwork and unique strength for his size added to his scoring ability. McGinnis spent the prime of his career in the ABA. Led the ABA in scoring in 1975 and was league MVP. McGinnis was a six time ABA & NBA all-star.

8) Bernard King
Best Season: 32.9 PPG, 5.8 RPG, 3.7 APG, 1.3 SPG, FG% .530
Bernard could get buckets with the best of them. A great mid range jump shooter and strong post player with a bevy of inside offensive moves. King scored over 20 points per game in 10 different seasons. The Brooklyn native ruled New York basketball in the early 1980s, once dropping 60 on Christmas day in the Garden. Riddled with injuries later in his career he was only at the peak of his powers for a few seasons. King managed to play in four all star games and led the league in scoring during the 1984-1985 campaign.

9) Tony Parker
Best Season: 20.3 PPG, 3.0 RPG, 7.6 APG, FG% .522
The only active player on our list, Tony Parker has help led San Antonio to four NBA championships. Parker is a consistent leader who rarely gets the credit for being as effective as he is. Instead Chris Paul has long received credit when Parker was the top player at the position. The 2007 NBA Finals MVP seems to led all point guards in points in the paint annually. A six time all-star and four time all-NBA team selection still has years ahead to build on an impressive resume.

10) Michael Cooper
Best Season: 11.9 PPG, 3.5 RPG, 3.0 APG, 1.6 SPG, FG% .517
The defensive MVP for the Showtime Lakers of the 1980s. He helped to cover up for Magic Johnson's serious defensive deficiencies. Copper was constantly challenged with the task of slowing down the opponents biggest offensive threat. Blessed with long arms and elite athleticism Cooper was able to stifle the best offensive players in the game. The 1987 winner of the Defensive player of the year award, was considered the best perimeter defender in the game. He was also able to contribute on offensive, running the floor and hitting the open jump shot. Undervalued on absolutely loaded Laker squads.

Honorable Mention - (Chauncey Billups, Alvin Robertson, Sidney Moncrief, Ben Wallace, Glen Rice, Guy Rodgers, Paul Arizin, Dominique Wilkins, Paul Pierce, Dennis Johnson, Dave Cowens, Jerry Lucas, Bobby Jones, Lenny Wilkins, Bob Lainer, Xavier McDaniel, Spencer Haywood, David Thompson, Mark Price, Alonzo Mourning, John Stockton, Marques Johnson)
Back to blog

13 comments

Rated fine: Clyde Drexler, Rasheed Wallace, Walter Davis, Connie Hawkins, Pistol Pete, Alex English, Brandon Roy. – People know them fine. Same with Bob Pettit, David Thompson, Bob Cousy, Elgin Baylor. – There are like alot of top 50 NBA guys here, people know them.

They were overrated all of them. So many horrible clutch performances in this list and not exactly an ego free list. This is a great overrated list so thanks for that. Sure a lot of them have talent, but im not any of these guys actually help a team get wins. In fact most teams were better when the following players were traded, Adrian Dantley, Mark Aguirre, Maurice Lucas, Jerome Kersey, Terry Porter, Danny Granger, Corey Maggette, Ron Harper, Cedric Ceballos, Nic Batum, Tom Chambers, Jimmy Jackson, Jalen Rose, Lamarcus Aldridge, Antawn Jameson, Kendall Gill, Kevin Duckworth, Kenny Anderson, Elden Campbell, Monte Ellis, Ricky Pierce, Tony Campbell, Shawn Kemp, Orlando Woolridge, Jason Richardson, Horace and Harvey Grant, Isaiah Rider. The finals moments for so many above were cringe worthy basketball. Winning counts for something, jacking up shots to get your stats up in the last 5 minutes of the game is not underrated.

Underrated: Rod Strickland, David West, Larry Nance, Terrell Brandon, Tayshaun Prince, Eddie Jones, Arvydas Sabonis, Kiki VanDeWeghe, Kevin Johnson, Eddie Johnson, Dale Ellis, Richard Hamilton, Detlef Schrempf, Cliff Robinson, Jerry Stackhouse, Otis Birdsong, Zack Randolph, Terry Cummings, or Mitch Richmond. – These guys are underrated.

You sound pretty sure of yourself that the 80s Lakers would have won without Cooper, but that team played no defense, Magic, Kareem, Rambis, they didn’t guard people like that. Bird might have scored 80 on them a couple of times without Cooper.

Legends

Rated fine: Clyde Drexler, Rasheed Wallace, Walter Davis, Connie Hawkins, Pistol Pete, Alex English, Brandon Roy. – People know them fine. Same with Bob Pettit, David Thompson, Bob Cousy, Elgin Baylor. – There are like alot of top 50 NBA guys here, people know them.

They were overrated all of them. So many horrible clutch performances in this list and not exactly an ego free list. This is a great overrated list so thanks for that. Sure a lot of them have talent, but im not any of these guys actually help a team get wins. In fact most teams were better when the following players were traded, Adrian Dantley, Mark Aguirre, Maurice Lucas, Jerome Kersey, Terry Porter, Danny Granger, Corey Maggette, Ron Harper, Cedric Ceballos, Nic Batum, Tom Chambers, Jimmy Jackson, Jalen Rose, Lamarcus Aldridge, Antawn Jameson, Kendall Gill, Kevin Duckworth, Kenny Anderson, Elden Campbell, Monte Ellis, Ricky Pierce, Tony Campbell, Shawn Kemp, Orlando Woolridge, Jason Richardson, Horace and Harvey Grant, Isaiah Rider. The finals moments for so many above were cringe worthy basketball. Winning counts for something, jacking up shots to get your stats up in the last 5 minutes of the game is not underrated.

Underrated: Rod Strickland, David West, Larry Nance, Terrell Brandon, Tayshaun Prince, Eddie Jones, Arvydas Sabonis, Kiki VanDeWeghe, Kevin Johnson, Eddie Johnson, Dale Ellis, Richard Hamilton, Detlef Schrempf, Cliff Robinson, Jerry Stackhouse, Otis Birdsong, Zack Randolph, Terry Cummings, or Mitch Richmond. – These guys are underrated.

You sound pretty sure of yourself that the 80s Lakers would have won without Cooper, but that team played no defense, Magic, Kareem, Rambis, they didn’t guard people like that. Bird might have scored 80 on them a couple of times without Cooper.

Legends

I’m sorry for the following what’s sure to be a long rant, but this list is pretty awful with some of the picks. Most of the top ten i can agree with mostly, but Michael Cooper is ridiculous. He was truly underrated – no doubt, and key to the Lakers dominance in the 80’s. That said, he was the sixth man on that team and though he was an awesome defender – he wasn’t thaaaat good to make up for the fact he barely averaged double figures in scoring for his career. As underrated as he was, there’s a minimum of 60 or so players who are far more deserving to be on this list than he. The fact of the matter is the only reason he’s so widely recognized for being so underrated is the simply fact that he was on that Lakers 80’s dynasty team, if he had played anywhere else aside for maybe the Celts, he wouldn’t be even an afterthought. There are literally at east 15 or more players in just the 1980’s alone, who are more deserving to make this list. How can you justify him being listed, or honorable mentions like DJ and Chauncey Billups, and yet not having the likes of: Clyde Drexler, Rasheed Wallace, Walter Davis, Adrian Dantley, Mark Aguirre, Maurice Lucas, Connie Hawkins, Pistol Pete, Alex English, Jerome Kersey, Rod Strickland, Terry Porter, David West, Danny Granger, Corey Maggette, Ron Harper, Cedric Ceballos, Nic Batum, Tom Chaimbers, Larry Nance, Terrell Brandon, Jimmy Jackson, Tayshaun Prince, Jalen Rose, Eddie Jones, Antawn Jameson, Kendall Gill, Lamarcus Aldridge, Brandon Roy, Arvydas Sabonis, Kiki VanDeWeghe, Kevin Johnson, Kevin Duckworth, Eddie Johnson, Dale Ellis, Richard Hamilton, Detlef Schrempf, Kenny Anderson, Elden Campbell, Monte Ellis, Ricky Pierce, Tony Campbell, Shawn Kemp, Orlando Woolridge, Jason Richardson, Horace and Harvey Grant, Cliff Robinson, Jerry Stackhouse, Isaiah Rider, Jason Richardson, Otis Birdsong, Zack Randolph, Terry Cummings, Kevin Willis, or Mitch Richmond?! Every single one of those guys I listed were either better players or that the amount to which they are/were underrated is greater than the three previously mentioned players im taking issue with being on this list, Hell – many of those players I listed aren’t just one or the other, but are in fact both better all-around players as well as being even more criminally underrated. And this is far from a comprehensive list – they’re just the ones i can think of off the top of my head!

Jesse Haffner

what about the most unselfish player of all-time, wes unseld. He was the best small center ever. He was able to defend wilt, kareem, thurmond and every other big center and win time after time. The outlet pass that unseld possessed was legendary and his picks were the best ever. He rarely ever took a bad shot and was one of the best rebounders of all-time. I hope people never forget how great wes unseld was and i know the terrific elvin hayes knows how unbelievably tatented and underrated unseld was. rip wes.

anne ekren

You forgot Bob Pettit! He needs to be number 1! Bob Cousy and Elgin Baylor are also very often underrated.

buster

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.